Blog
Does Putting a Hole in a Dummy Work?
Many parents, when faced with the challenge of dummy weaning, ask: does putting a hole in a dummy help? The idea sounds clever – make the dummy less satisfying, and maybe your little one will lose interest. But is it safe? And does it actually work?
This guide dives into the method of putting a small hole in a dummy, what to expect, and whether it’s the right step for your child. We’ll also explore safer, expert-recommended alternatives — because your child’s safety and comfort always come first.
Table of Contents
Why Babies Love Dummies
Babies aren’t just sucking for the fun of it – there’s science behind it. Dummies satisfy an instinctive need known as non-nutritive sucking, which helps soothe and calm babies. That’s why they can be such a lifesaver during sleep times, car journeys, and teething phases.
But as your baby grows, their attachment to the dummy can become more emotional than physical – which is where the struggle begins. Weaning off the dummy means helping your child give up not just a habit, but a comfort object.
What Happens If You Put a Hole in a Dummy?
The idea behind this technique is simple: by poking a small hole in the dummy’s teat, the suction is reduced, and it’s no longer as satisfying. Over time, the child may lose interest and stop using it altogether.
Parent Experiences
Some parents say it worked a treat – especially when done gradually. They started with a tiny pinhole and increased it over days or weeks, leading their child to naturally stop reaching for it.
Others saw a more dramatic effect: a bigger hole caused instant rejection of the dummy – but also tears and disrupted sleep if not handled carefully.
🍼 Important Note: There’s no clinical evidence proving this works. It’s purely anecdotal — and how your child responds can vary.
But Is It Safe?
Here’s the honest truth: modifying a dummy in any way comes with risks.
⚠️ Potential Hazards:
- Choking risk – The teat could tear or detach, especially after being weakened.
- Bacteria build-up – A hole or tear may trap moisture and become unhygienic.
- Goes against safety standards – Dummies are tested for safety as a whole product. Once modified, they no longer meet regulations like BSEN 1400.
Even top health organisations and dummy manufacturers strongly recommend never using a damaged or altered dummy. If it’s torn, worn, or modified – it should be replaced.
Thinking of Trying It? Do It Safely
If you still want to test this method, make sure to follow these safety tips:
✅ Safer Steps:
- Start tiny – Use a sterile needle, not scissors.
- Check daily – Look for signs of damage or wear.
- Keep clean – Wash with warm, soapy water. Don’t boil.
- Watch closely – Supervise use, especially during the day.
And remember: if the dummy shows any cracks, holes growing larger, or changes in shape — bin it immediately.
Better Alternatives to Dummy Modifying
Want to wean your child off the dummy without the risks? Try these expert-backed ideas instead:
1. Gradual Weaning
Only offer the dummy at nap or bedtime. Slowly reduce use over 1–2 weeks.
2. The Dummy Fairy
Let your child leave their dummy out for the “fairy” to collect in exchange for a gift. It gives them a sense of control and celebration.
3. Cold Turkey
Some parents swear by simply removing the dummy and sticking to it. It can be tough at first – but often short-lived.
4. Story-Based Goodbyes
Books and songs about giving up dummies help toddlers feel part of a bigger moment.
Final Thoughts: Should You Put a Hole in a Dummy?
So, does putting a hole in a dummy work? For some, yes – but it’s a gamble, and one that may come with unnecessary risk. Most experts agree: it’s not worth compromising your child’s safety over.
Stick with safe, gradual weaning techniques, stay consistent, and offer lots of reassurance along the way. Every child is different – and however you get there, saying goodbye to the dummy is a milestone worth celebrating.
💡 Looking for safe, CE-certified dummy clips?
Explore our Wooden, Silicone, and Fabric collections — perfect for keeping dummies clean, secure, and stylish
